The calendar has turned to May, so we've had a month of baseball to enjoy. Even though it's only a month worth of results, I thought it might be fun to review our top prospects lists and see if anyone is looking way to high or low based on what we saw in April. The actual RaysProspects Top 15's are on the sidebar -->, but lets take a look at our individual lists (Kevin, Jake, Andy, and I did ours in November) plus Baseball America's list (done in early February), Stacy Long's list (done in December) and John Sickels' list (don't remember when his came out).
So have at it in the comments, who's list looks the best, who's worst, and who did the consensus miss on based on what we've seen so far. Here are the lists:
Rk Player JS BA SL JL AL KG DM Pts 1. Desmond Jennings 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 210 2. Jeremy Hellickson 2 2 2 2 4 3 3 199 3. Wade Davis 3 3 3 4 2 2 2 198 4. Matt Moore 4 4 4 5 6 4 4 186 5. Reid Brignac 6 5 7 6 3 5 5 180 6. Tim Beckham 8 6 5 3 5 6 10 174 7t. Nick Barnese 9 10 6 8 9 8 9 158 7t. Alexander Colome 5 7 10 10 7 9 11 158 9. Kyle Lobstein 12 11 9 7 10 10 6 152 10. Alexander Torres 7 9 12 16 12 11 12 138 11. Jake McGee 18 8 8 -- 11 15 20 106 12. Kyeong Kang 14 31 13 19 15 18 8 100 13t. Alex Cobb 17 21 18 30 18 7 7 99 13t. Luke Bailey 11 12 -- 9 13 21 21 99 15. Wilking Rodriguez 10 17 -- 11 17 17 17 97 16. Matt Gorgen 20 28 16 13 28 13 14 85 17. David Newmann 19 23 15 -- 16 14 16 83 18. Matt Sweeney 15 24 19 29 8 22 18 82 19. Jason McEachern HM 25 21 15 24 12 13 77 20. Todd Glaesmann 16 16 -- 12 19 23 24 76 21. Shawn O'Malley -- 18 17 17 -- 16 23 64 22. Joseph Cruz HM 13 -- -- 25 20 15 52 23. Aneury Rodriguez 13 27 14 -- 30 -- 22 49 24. Jeff Malm HM 19 -- 14 20 24 -- 48 25. Ty Morrison HM 14 -- 24 21 25 -- 41 26t. Mitch Talbot -- -- 25 -- 14 30 19 36 26t. Fernando Perez HM 15 11 -- -- -- -- 36 28. Hector Guevara HM -- -- 20 22 19 29 35 29. Cody Rogers HM 22 -- 22 -- 28 25 28 30. Jacob Partridge HM -- -- 21 -- 27 27 19 31t. Nevin Ashley HM -- 28 18 -- -- 30 18 31t. John Jaso HM -- 22 -- 23 -- -- 18 33. Heath Rollins HM -- 20 -- 26 -- -- 17 34. Albert Suarez -- 20 -- -- 27 -- -- 15 35. Kevin James HM 30 -- 26 -- 26 -- 12 36. Jake Jefferies HM 29 -- 25 29 -- -- 11 37. Frank De Los Santos -- 26 -- -- -- -- 26 10 38t. Jeremy Hall -- -- 23 -- -- -- -- 8 38t. Cesar Perez -- -- -- 23 -- -- -- 8 40. Eduardo Morlan -- -- 24 -- -- -- -- 7 41. Dale Thayer -- -- 26 -- -- -- -- 5 42t. Zach Quate HM -- 30 -- -- 29 -- 4 42t. Darin Downs -- -- 27 -- -- -- -- 4 42t. Mike Sheridan -- -- -- 27 -- -- -- 4 45t. Victor Mateo -- -- -- -- -- -- 28 3 45t. Wester Silva -- -- -- 28 -- -- -- 3 47. Cody Cipriano -- -- 29 -- -- -- -- 2 48t. Tyler Bortnick HM -- -- -- -- -- -- 1 48t. Devin Fuller HM -- -- -- -- -- -- 1 48t. Rayner Oliveros HM -- -- -- -- -- -- 1 48t. Scott Shuman HM -- -- -- -- -- -- 1Notes: JS is John Sickels, BA is Baseball America, SL is Stacy Long, JL is Jake Larsen, AL is Andy Leslie, KG is Kevin Gengler, and DM is me. Points are 30 for 1st, 29 for 2nd, etc. I gave one point to each Honorable Mention or "other" by Sickels. On Mitch Talbot, JS and BA did their lists after he was traded to Cleveland, the rest of us did ours before the trade. On Fernando Perez, most of us didn't consider him eligible, some did (MLB DL time counts as service time, so I say no).
No comments:
Post a Comment