Combined Top 30 Lists With Notes

Here are our top 30s re-printed in one post, followed by a combined list. I simply awarded 30 points for 1st place, 29 for 2nd place, etc. So Jeremy Hellickson, who all three of us had #1, received 30 points three times for a total of 90.

Rank Doug Milhoan        Rank Jake Larsen         Rank Kevin Gengler
1    Jeremy Hellickson   1    Jeremy Hellickson   1    Jeremy Hellickson
2    Matt Moore          2    Desmond Jennings    2    Matt Moore
3    Desmond Jennings    3    Matt Moore          3    Desmond Jennings
4    Alex Cobb           4    Joseph Cruz         4    Alex Torres
5    Jake McGee          5    Josh Sale           5    Alex Cobb
6    Alex Colome         6    Alex Cobb           6    Alex Colome
7    Alex Torres         7    Alex Torres         7    Jake McGee
8    Jake Thompson       8    Nick Barnese        8    Josh Sale
9    Joseph Cruz         9    Alex Colome         9    Joseph Cruz
10   Drew Vettleson      10   Jake Thompson       10   Nick Barnese

11   Josh Sale           11   Wilking Rodriguez   11   Jake Thompson
12   Nick Barnese        12   Jake McGee          12   Wilking Rodriguez
13   Tyler Bortnick      13   Enny Romero         13   Justin O'Conner
14   Enny Romero         14   Ryan Brett          14   Luke Bailey
15   Wilking Rodriguez   15   Drew Vettleson      15   Drew Vettleson
16   Justin O'Conner     16   Derek Dietrich      16   Tim Beckham
17   Albert Suarez       17   Yoel Araujo         17   Ty Morrison
18   Scott Shuman        18   Hector Guevara      18   Derek Dietrich
19   Luke Bailey         19   Tim Beckham         19   Enny Romero
20   Tim Beckham         20   Justin O'Conner     20   Ryan Brett

21   Kyle Lobstein       21   Luke Bailey         21   Scott Shuman
22   Stephen Vogt        22   Jake DePew          22   Hector Guevara
23   Shane Dyer          23   Jeff Malm           23   Todd Glaesmann
24   Wilmer Almonte      24   Scott Shuman        24   Tyler Bortnick
25   Ryan Brett          25   Todd Glaesmann      25   Albert Suarez
26   Aneury Rodriguez*   26   Tyler Bortnick      26   Jesse Hahn
27   Zach Quate          27   Cesar Perez         27   Kyle Lobstein
28   Todd Glaesmann      28   Jesse Hahn          28   Zach Quate
29   Ty Morrison         29   Zach Quate          29   Cesar Perez
30   Derek Dietrich      30   Ty Morrison         30   Braulio Lara
*Selected by Houston Astros in Rule 5 Draft

And the combined list (the numbers under the DM, JL, and KG columns are the ranking we gave them individually, not the points):

Rank Player             Pts   DM  JL  KG    
1    Jeremy Hellickson   90    1   1   1
2    Matt Moore          86    2   3   2
3    Desmond Jennings    85    3   2   3
4    Alex Cobb           78    4   6   5
5    Alex Torres         75    7   7   4
6    Alex Colome         72    6   9   6
7    Joseph Cruz         71    9   4   9
T-8  Josh Sale           69   11   5   8
T-8  Jake McGee          69    5  12   7
10   Jake Thompson       64    8  10  11

11   Nick Barnese        63   12   8  10
12   Wilking Rodriguez   55   15  11  12
13   Drew Vettleson      53   10  15  15
14   Enny Romero         47   14  13  19
15   Justin O'Conner     44   16  20  13
16   Luke Bailey         39   19  21  14
17   Tim Beckham         38   20  19  16
18   Ryan Brett          34   25  14  20
T-19 Tyler Bortnick      30   13  26  24
T-19 Scott Shuman        30   18  24  21

21   Derek Dietrich      29   30  16  18
22   Hector Guevara      21   --  18  22
23   Albert Suarez       20   17  --  25
T-24 Ty Morrison         17   29  30  17
T-24 Todd Glaesmann      17   28  25  23
T-26 Kyle Lobstein       14   21  --  27
T-26 Yoel Araujo         14   --  17  --
T-28 Zach Quate           9   27  29  28
T-28 Stephen Vogt         9   22  --  --
T-28 Jake Depew           9   --  22  --

T-31 Shane Dyer           8   23  --  --
T-31 Jeff Malm            8   --  23  --
T-31 Jesse Hahn           8   --  28  26
34   Wilmer Almonte       7   24  --  --
35   Cesar Perez          6   --  27  29
36   Aneury Rodriguez*    5   26  --  --
37   Braulio Lara         1   --  --  30
*Selected by Houston Astros in Rule 5 Draft

Notes:
1. Between, the three of us, 37 total players were ranked. Last season, with an extra ranker (Andy Leslie), 41 total players were ranked.

2. In all, 24 players were ranked in the top 30 by all three of us. 5 players were ranked by two of us, and 8 players were listed on just one ballot.

3. All three of us had 9 of the combined top 10 in our personal top 10 lists. Doug had Drew Vettleson in his top 10, while Jake and I both had Nick Barnese in our top 10s.

4. Of players who were ranked by all three of us, Derek Dietrich had the widest range. He was as high as 16 on Jake's list and as low as 30 on Doug's.

5. The top 10 contains 8 pitchers and 2 hitters. 11-20 has 4 pitchers and 6 hitters. 21-30 features 3 pitchers and 7 hitters. 31-37 has 5 pitchers and 2 hitters. So in total, the top 37 has 20 pitchers and 17 hitters, but the talent up top is clearly in the pitching.